Winnipeg Jets Overreached on Hellebuyck Trade, Says Ex‑Sabre

Winnipeg Jets' aggressive push for a Connor Hellebuyck trade has backfired, former Buffalo Sabres forward Tim Connolly warned on Tuesday, saying the club overplayed its hand and may have hurt its own bargaining position. The Jets sit 12th in the Western Conference with a 35-35 record and are on a four‑game losing streak as they prepare to face the Edmonton Oilers on September 20.

What did Connolly say?

Connolly, who spent six seasons with the Sabres, told reporters the Jets' approach was "too aggressive" and left little room for negotiation. He pointed out that Hellebuyck, the Jets' All‑Star goaltender, is under a long‑term contract that includes a hefty no‑trade clause, making any deal complex. "You can't just walk in and demand a star goalie without offering something that matches his value," Connolly explained, noting that the Jets seemed to think they could force a bargain.

Why does this matter for the Jets?

The criticism hits at a time when Winnipeg is struggling to climb the standings. Their .500 record reflects inconsistency on both ends of the ice, and a failed trade could further destabilize the roster. Coach Rick Bowness relies heavily on Hellebuyck's steady presence; losing him without adequate return would force the Jets to lean on backup goalies like Daniil Tarasov, who has posted a 2.78 GAA this season. The team’s power‑play, currently at 18.9%, could also suffer without Hellebuyck's confidence‑boosting saves.

How could the trade scenario unfold?

If the Jets persist, they may need to package a top‑six forward, a promising prospect, and a first‑round pick to meet Hellebuyck's market value. Potential suitors include the New York Rangers, who have cap space, and the Toronto Maple Leafs, looking to shore up their net. However, any deal must respect Hellebuyck's no‑trade clause, meaning he would need to approve the destination. Connolly warned that pushing too hard could see Hellebuyck stay put, leaving the Jets with a depleted asset pool.

What’s next for Winnipeg?

The Jets head into their next game against the Edmonton Oilers on September 20, a matchup that could signal whether the trade chatter is distracting the squad. A win would give Bowness a chance to refocus his players, while a loss might amplify calls for a front‑office shake‑up. Meanwhile, general manager Kevin Cheveldayoff is expected to address the rumors at the upcoming press conference, likely emphasizing the team's commitment to competing now rather than chasing a blockbuster deal.

How fans are reacting

Local fans have taken to social media, with many echoing Connolly's sentiment. Some argue the Jets should prioritize developing young talent over chasing a veteran goalie, while others believe Hellebuyck’s elite play is worth the risk. Ticket sales have dipped slightly in recent weeks, and a high‑profile trade could either revive interest or deepen the disappointment if it falls through.

The Jets' next steps will reveal whether they can salvage their season or if the Hellebuyck saga will become another cautionary tale of overreaching in the NHL.